533 Bay Street
Staten Island · 10304 · BBL 5004900004 · look up another building
Registered rent-stabilized units here went from 67 in 2019 to 65 in 2022.
Most recent filing on this building: a violation, October 1, 2026
533 Bay Street is a multi-family elevator building in Stapleton, Staten Island, ZIP 10304. City records date it to 2016 and count 67 apartments. The city's property file lists the owner of record as BAY STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORP . Its total assessed value is $3.9M, for the 2026 tax year.
DHCR registration lists 65 rent-stabilized units here in 2022, but that is the building and not your apartment. The state will send you your own rent history free, and it is the only binding answer on what you should be paying.
Know the month this building changes
Most buildings here are quiet. Two filings a year is normal, so most months there's nothing to report on 533 Bay Street and we'll say so. The point is the month we do
Taxes and assessed value for 533 Bay Street
The city's Department of Finance assessed this lot at $3.9M for the 2026 tax year. That works out to $58K per residential unit. Assessed value is what the city taxes, not what the building would sell for, and the two routinely differ by a wide margin. The bill itself turns on the tax class rate and on any exemptions or abatements attached to the lot, neither of which is published here.
6 marshal evictions at 533 Bay Street
City marshals executed 6 evictions at 533 Bay Street in the record PulseCities holds, the most recent on Jul 23, 2026. The first fell on Oct 3, 2024, so the filings span 21 months. That is more than 9 in 10 buildings its size in Staten Island. Holding the marshal docket number or the court index number from one of these? Look up that case →
Marshal evictions at 533 Bay Street
| Type | Executed | |
|---|---|---|
| Residentialdocket 142773 | Jul 23, 2026 | |
| Residentialdocket 140648 | Dec 4, 2025 |
Marshal-executed residential evictions from the NYC evictions dataset, past 12 months. Source: NYC marshal eviction records, current through October 9, 2026.
Rent stabilization at 533 Bay Street
DHCR registration records list 65 rent-stabilized units at this building in 2022, the most recent year PulseCities holds. That is down from 67 units in 2019. Registration is building-level and does not settle the status of any single apartment; the rent history does. Checking your own apartment starts with the free rent history from the state. That is the only binding answer, and it takes time to come back. While you wait, you can get an email when the record here moves: a deed, an eviction, a permit or a violation filed on this building. How to check rent-stabilized status →
Open code violations at 533 Bay Street
HPD and DOB inspectors have written 88 violations against this building, of which 30 remain unresolved. That is more than 8 in 10 buildings its size in Staten Island. The most serious open grade here is immediately hazardous, with 6 open violations.
Classes run A (non-hazardous) to C (immediately hazardous); DOB class I carries a vacate order. Source: NYC HPD violations, current through October 10, 2026.
Violation history at 533 Bay Street
| Violation | Issued | Class |
|---|---|---|
| Replace or repair the self-closing doors that is missing or defective latch at hopper door inside compactor cl…Violation Will Be Reinspected | Oct 1, 2026 | C |
| Repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at south wall in the bathroomNov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | A |
| Cleanse to the satisfaction of this department the mildew on grout around bathtub in the bathroomNov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | A |
| Repair, replace or provide an approved and operational carbon monoxide detecting device, installed in accordan…Nov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | B |
| Repair, replace or provide an approved and operational smoke detecting device, installed in accordance with de…Nov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | B |
| Replace with new the missing wood saddle at floor in the entrance in the 1st room from east at northNov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | B |
| Repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at ceiling and south wall in th…Nov Sent Out | Oct 1, 2026 | A |
| Trace and repair the source and abate the visible mold condition... greater than 10 sq ft observed at ceiling…Notice Of Issuance Sent To Tenant | Oct 1, 2026 | B |
The 8 most recent violations written against this building, newest first, 7 of them still open. Each row is the inspector's own wording with the statute citation removed. Source: NYC HPD violations, current through October 10, 2026.
311 complaint history at 533 Bay Street
22 complaints in the past 12 months
NYC 311 housing and building complaints logged for this address. Source: NYC 311, current through October 10, 2026.
How 533 Bay Street compares in 10304
PulseCities tracks 9,371 lots in 10304, of which 103 carry an executed eviction from the marshal record, which starts in April 2024, and 0 carry a deed from the shorter ACRIS window. This building is in that second group, which is 1.1% of the ZIP. 10304 scores 15.2 out of 100 for displacement pressure, 151 of 177 scored NYC ZIP codes. The full signal breakdown for Stapleton →
Questions about 533 Bay Street
Who owns 533 Bay Street?
The city's property file lists BAY STREET HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORP . as the owner of record for 533 Bay Street. No deed for this lot appears in the ACRIS records PulseCities holds, so that name comes from the tax roll rather than from a recorded transfer.
Has 533 Bay Street changed hands recently?
No deed for 533 Bay Street appears in the ACRIS records PulseCities holds. That means no transfer has been published for this lot in the current window, not that the building has never been sold.
Have there been evictions at 533 Bay Street?
Yes. Six marshal-executed evictions at 533 Bay Street appear in the NYC evictions dataset, the most recent on Jul 23, 2026. The dataset covers executed evictions only, so it undercounts housing court activity: cases that settle or end in a move-out never reach a marshal.
Is 533 Bay Street rent stabilized?
DHCR registrations list 65 stabilized units at this building in 2022. Registration is building-level, so it does not settle whether one apartment is stabilized. The free rent history from NYS Homes and Community Renewal does.
What is 533 Bay Street assessed at for property taxes?
The Department of Finance assessed the lot at $3.9M for the 2026 tax year. That is the figure the city taxes rather than a sale price, and the bill depends on the tax class rate and on any exemptions on the lot.
What is the displacement risk around 533 Bay Street?
10304 (Stapleton) scores 15.2 out of 100 on the PulseCities displacement index. The score reads five ZIP-level signals: LLC acquisition rate, permit intensity, 311 complaint volume, executed evictions, and serious HPD violations. It describes the area around the building, not the building itself.
Look up another building
Sourced from NYC public records: ACRIS deeds, DOB permits, the NYC evictions dataset, and 311. Records reflect what agencies have published and can lag events.